Smart bridge
structures use fiber optic sensors
On Leslie Street, in the northern part of Toronto, a forest of concrete columns
supports a multi-lane bridge, part of the citys main thoroughfare of Highway 401. It
doesnt look much different from any other highway bridge in the city, but the
columns supporting it possess two unique features both firsts in the province.
- Two of the columns have dormant intelligence, instrumented with the first experimental
long gauge fiber optic sensors ever manufactured or field tested in Canada.
- Four columns are wrapped to a height of about seven feet with advanced composite
materials (ACMs) extremely strong and lightweight synthetic material such as
carbon-fiber or glass-fiber reinforced composite materials.
The columns are an experimental part of a new trend in civil engineering called smart
structures, incorporating sensors in some of the most advanced building materials ever
used in bridge construction. The critical deterioration of transportation infrastructure
across the continent, including highways and bridges, has driven the search for new
methods of concrete rehabilitation and repair. These advanced composite materials are the
leading edge of civil engineering technology, at a fraction of the weight and orders of
magnitude stronger than conventional construction materials.
New tech experiments
Ontarios Ministry of Transportation scheduled the conventional concrete column
repair on the Leslie Street bridge for 1996 and decided to experiment with ACM wraps
instrumented with fiber optic strain sensors, and with reference cells to measure the
progress of corrosion. A readout is shown in the photo above.
The optical sensors were designed, manufactured, and installed by research engineers at
the Fibre Optic Sensing laboratory of the University of Toronto Institute for Aerospace
Studies. The UTIAS FOS laboratory, headed by Dr. R.C. Tennyson, is a research member of
Intelligent Sensing for Innovative Structures (ISIS) Canada, a federal Network Centre of
Excellence.
"Since the [ACM] wraps are impervious to air, water, and chloride, they may
protect steel reinforcements," said Frank Pianca, of MTOs Research and
Development Branch, "but we need to see if moisture and oxygen enter from the top or
bottom of the column. Were monitoring to see how effective it is and well need
to follow the corrosion performance of the column for about three to five years."
Advanced experimentation with ACMs includes the installation of fiber optic sensors
under the wraps that allow highway engineers to keep track of what is happening to the
concrete columns underneath. The sensors precisely measure expansion or contraction of the
concrete, and these measurements may indicate the effect of corrosion inside the column.
The fiber optic sensors are the same kind of hair-thin fiber optic cables used for
telecommunications, but wrapped around or embedded in concrete structures. A short section
of fiber optic cable is stripped of its protective coating and treated with
high-intensity, ultra-violet beams to create a sensing region. This sensing region is, in
fact, the sensor, which can deliver measurements of concrete stresses and strains for
computer analysis.
Most fiber optic sensors for civil engineering are approximately 1- to 1.5-in. long and
provide measurements of temperature and defined points of strain.
One-of-a-kind sensors
The experimental sensors on the Leslie Street bridge, however, are 10-ft. long
one-of-a-kind, custom-made sensors with length equal to the circumference of the columns.
When the steel reinforcement inside the column is contaminated by salt and moisture, the
steel begins to rust, expand, and crack the surrounding concrete columns.
Highway engineers are testing ACM wraps to see if they can reduce and/or delay the
corrosion inside the columns, and, consequently, bridge repair and road closures. The long
gauge sensors installed on the Leslie Street bridge precisely measure the total column
expansion, providing valuable data on the state of the column underneath the repair wraps,
while the reference cells are used to measure corrosion potential.
"What we are looking for is displacement of any kind," said UTIAS FOS
laboratory research engineer Paul Mulvihill. "If the columns have widened, that could
be an indication of corrosion. If there is no displacement if the columns
havent expanded thats an indication that the ACM wraps are doing their
job."
The sensor readings were calibrated at the time of installation in 1996. In March,
1998, the second set of readings provided the first hard evidence of the viability of
these experimental long gauge sensors, and the clear potential of ACM wraps. When the
readings from the bridge were analyzed shortly after they were taken, all five sensors
initially installed were found to be fully operational, and the two wrapped columns
instrumented with the sensors changed in circumference only a minuscule amount the
first column expanded by an average of 5871 microns (about 5.9 millimeters), and the
second column expanded by an average of 6259 microns (about 6.3 millimeters). While
readings will continue to be taken, statistically, these measurements indicate no
significant column change.
Mulvihill said, "This kind of sensor and this kind of instrument dont exist
anywhere else in the world. We were pleased that we were able to get signals from all five
of these sensors embedded for over a year-and-a-half. In addition to strain sensing, we
found the sensors were also picking up traffic load from the bridge thats
something we didnt see in the lab."
Reprinted from Better Roads Magazine
September 1998 |